First off I wanted to thank everybody who entered our Inaugural ‘First Line’ Short Story Competition. I was suitably impressed with the response, enough so that I will hold another, but more of that later.
Having read and reread entries I think I can safely say I have, for the moment, had my fair share of spreading crimson puddles of wine, blood and tomato ketchup, and the journals of those recently departed. But it was entertaining to see how everybody took the selected first lines on different journeys.
In fact this was my first deciding factor in the judging. To me a strong story is everything; even if you have perfect writing skills it won’t help a weak or implausible story. However, in my mind, if you have a strong story, occasionally lapses in writing techniques can be overlooked.
I was looking for the unexpected in the plot, something that delighted or surprised me, something that flowed seamlessly, had impact or perhaps something that reflected so closely to humanity that it caught my breath. This is where the pile of possible winners really shrank dramatically.
There was a wide array of storylines and it was a wonder that there were no similar stories, especially considering how so many went in similar directions. The diversity of the creative mind has always kept me guessing.
Anyway, once I had selected my favourite plots from there I went through focusing more closely on the writing techniques, although in most cases that simply came down to the quality of proof-reading. It’s a line that’s so often repeated in Judge’s Reports that I was almost loathed to mention it, but I decided I would for future reference – please proof read your work or get somebody else to, it does make a huge difference.
My other comment for future reference is: please read and follow the submission guidelines. Since this is our first competition and the request was different from most other competitions I wasn’t too strict on the ‘print on both sides of the paper’ but next time I’m afraid I will. I’m a greenie at heart and wherever I can feasibly save trees I will.
So I guess you want to know what won and why?
FIRST PRIZE
‘Hell’s Kitchen’ by Susan May
I chose this one because it was topical with a smooth twist that was unexpected and clear. The vocabulary was diverse and varied, without having to resort to unusual or clunky words. The character and his emotion was strong: I was there with him fighting to save the Beef Bourguignon. What’s more all the clues were there to imply the ending but they were all woven in so well I didn’t realise until I read the final paragraphs.
SECOND PRIZE
‘Truth be Told’ by Sarah Jovanovski
This was a story that struck me because of the characters and the believability of the behaviours. The honesty of Noah’s feelings, thoughts and behaviour stayed with me long after I had finished the story. While I was hoping for a stronger ending, the fact that it wasn’t there and that there wasn’t a twist made it even more realistic and believable.
THIRD PRIZE
‘Secret Words’ to Susanna Freymark
Again, this is a story that tells of the pain and emotions that we live with when communicating with others. But what I liked about this one was how it showed one simple gesture and move can change the whole energy of a friendship and the way we look at the world around us. This was one of the few stories submitted that strongly implied hope for the future, if not the classical happy ending. It is a story that I believe any parent of a teenage child will associate with, and maybe also teenagers.
—
I find it interesting now that I look over the prize winning stories to see that they are all simply stories told with a strong voice and through strong characters. Perhaps another aspect to heed for next time.
Thank you again for entering the competition. For those that are interested in reading the winning stories I will endeavour to post them here shortly after the winners have been notified. And for those who are interested we will be announcing our next exciting competition very shortly.

Tags: Elizabeth Bezant, first sentences, Judges report, short story, writing, writing competition, Writing to Inspire (my business site)